The Best Perfect Cookie - February 2023

Based on the analysis of 17,078 reviews.

Rank		Manufacturer	Product	Score
1 Top Choice Best Value	Score: 9.4 Price: $$$ The Perfect Cookie: Your Ultimate Guide to Fool...	Americas Test Kitchen	The Perfect Cookie: Your Ultimate Guide to Foolproof Cookies, Brownies & Bars By Americas Test Kitchen 119 reviews	9.4	$$$ View Product
2	Score: 9 Price: $$$ Silpat AE420295-12 Perfect Cookie Baking Sheet	Silpat	Silpat AE420295-12 Perfect Cookie Baking Sheet By Silpat 155 reviews	9.0	$$$ View Product
3	Score: 9 Price: $$$ The Perfect Cake: Your Ultimate Guide to Classi...	America's Test Kitchen	The Perfect Cake: Your Ultimate Guide to Classic, Modern, and Whimsical Cakes By America's Test Kitchen 91 reviews	9.0	$$$ View Product
4 Best Seller	Score: 7.8 Price: $$$ A Good Bake: The Art and Science of Making Perf...		A Good Bake: The Art and Science of Making Perfect Pastries, Cakes, Cookies, Pies, and Breads at ... By Knopf 9 reviews	7.8	$$$ View Product
5	Score: 9 Price: $$$ ZonePerfect Protein Bars, Chocolate Chip Cookie...	Zoneperfect Classic	ZonePerfect Protein Bars, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, High Protein, With Vitamins & Minerals... By Zoneperfect Classic 152 reviews	9.0	$$$ View Product
6	Score: 9 Price: $$$$ ZonePerfect Nutrition Snack Bars, High Protein ...	Zone Perfect	ZonePerfect Nutrition Snack Bars, High Protein Energy Bars, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, 1.76 Oun... By Zone Perfect 1,420 reviews	9.0	$$$$ View Product
7	Score: 6.4 Price: $$$ NuGo Perfect Cookie, Double Dark Chocolate, 10g...	NuGo	NuGo Perfect Cookie, Double Dark Chocolate, 10g Vegan Protein, 2g Sugar, 190 Calorie, Gluten Free... By NuGo 3,556 reviews	6.4	$$$ View Product
8	Score: 8.6 Price: $$$$ How to Bake: Complete Guide to Perfect Cakes, C...		How to Bake: Complete Guide to Perfect Cakes, Cookies, Pies, Tarts, Breads, Pizzas, Muffins, Swee... 897 reviews	8.6	$$$$ View Product
9	Score: 10 Price: $$$ Perfect Keto Cookies - 12 Pack (24 Cookies) Low...	Perfect Keto	Perfect Keto Cookies - 12 Pack (24 Cookies) Low Net Carb Snacks & Sweets, No Added Sugar and Glut... By Perfect Keto 3,370 reviews	10.0	$$$ View Product
10	Score: 9.4 Price: $$$ 2 Baking Mats - Silicone, Food Safe Baking Mat,...	Actor	2 Baking Mats - Silicone, Food Safe Baking Mat, Tray Pan Liner Fat-free Dishes - Food-Grade Silic... By Actor 977 reviews	9.4	$$$ View Product

Top Perfect Cookie Brands

Americas Test Kitchen

America's Test Kitchen is a 2,500 square foot kitchen located out of Boston. It is the house of Cook's Illustrated and Cook's Country magazines and will be your workday destination for over 3 dozen evaluation cooks, editors and cookware specialists. Our duty is to examine recipes until we understand exactly how and why they operate and arrive in the very best version. We also test kitchen gear and supermarket components in search of brands that offer the best value and functionality. You can see us work by tuning into our public television show, America's Test Kitchen.

See all Americas Test Kitchen products